$2.9 Million Verdict Against Sonoma State University for Asbestos

Asbestos-Related Health Risks for California Off-Roading Enthusiasts
October 11, 2017
Judge Throws Out $417 Million Talcum Powder Verdict
October 25, 2017
cracked tile wall

We recently blogged here about the danger of asbestos-fiber release if a product containing the mineral is broken, crushed, sanded, cut or otherwise disturbed.

Once released into the airstream, people can breathe in or swallow the fibers, which become lodged in the lungs and elsewhere in the body, creating the risk of eventually developing fatal cancers or other serious diseases.

Asbestos-Containing Material Deterioration

In addition to cutting, breaking, or sanding asbestos-containing materials (ACMs), fibers can also be released into dust and air through normal wear and tear. ACMs are common components of many buildings – residential, commercial and public – especially older structures and often schools and universities. These are just a few examples of areas where asbestos can be found within educational facilities:

  • Insulation: Asbestos was commonly used in steam pipe and boiler insulation.
  • Construction: Asbestos products were used extensively in school construction, including in fireproofing, insulation, joint compounds, ceiling tiles, floor tiles, and plaster and patching compounds.
  • Pipes and plumbing: Plumbers and pipefitters may be exposed to asbestos when working with cement pipes, pipe coverings or boilers.

When these building materials start to wear out, they may crack, break, crumble or disintegrate. It was just this scenario that reportedly alarmed an employee of Sonoma State University (SSU) after 24 years of service to the school.

Retaliation Lawsuit

As SSU’s Environmental Health and Safety Specialist, the employee reported concerns to his employer about asbestos in deteriorating floor and ceiling tiles in Stevenson Hall, an older office building. According to The Press Democrat, he alleged that he experienced retaliation and hostility at work after reporting his concerns, forcing him to quit his job. He also alleged that the school did not sufficiently deal with the asbestos problem.

The employee filed a whistleblower lawsuit in state court and earlier this year, the jury awarded him almost $388,000 for lost wages, “mental suffering” and “emotional distress.” In September, the judge handed down an additional $2.9 million verdict, which includes penalties for occupational safety regulatory violations. The judge ordered that a portion was to go to each of 231 employees who worked in the building during the time at issue. A large part will also go to government officials. The court also ordered that the whistleblower be reinstated to his former job.

The university will reportedly appeal the ruling, during which the money and the reinstatement will be delayed pending resolution.

February 17, 2022

Sonoma State University’s Asbestos Woes Continue

Sonoma State University (SSU) has been fined $6,000 by the State after neglecting to follow safety rules and procedures while removing athletic tracks that contained asbestos (Gonzalez, 2018). Cal-OSHA cited SSU for seven violations including failure to provide workers with protective clothing and respirators and ensuring proper handling and disposal of the material. Thomas Sargent, [...]
February 27, 2018

Asbestos Found in Schools across the United States

Recently, asbestos has been causing havoc in schools around the country. Because of its durability and fire-resistant nature, asbestos-containing materials were commonly used in schools built between 1940 and 1970 (Dobbins, 2018). Since it is expensive and time-consuming to remove, schools often leave it concealed. As these schools start to deteriorate, asbestos can easily become [...]
August 31, 2017

Oregon School District Staff Exposed to Deadly Asbestos

The maintenance staff at Coos Bay School District was just finishing some routine work around the Harding School building before classes were scheduled to begin. Unfortunately, the District was notified that one of the maintenance employees had accidentally caused asbestos fibers to become airborne. Many school buildings contain some amount of asbestos, which is why [...]